War on Different Scales Addendum — The ETC Midgame
Addendum to my previous post: War on Different Scales
A few months ago, at the Ethereum Classic Summit, I gave a talk on a potential roadmap towards Proof of Stake. To be quite honest, I wasn’t really expecting the Ethereum Classic community to buy into the proposal. Rather just wanted to:
- Get the gears in their heads spinning a bit on the idea
- Use it as practice for a similar talk I gave a week later at Ethereum DevCon.
So the majority of the content between the two talks was the same, but there was one particular section that was unique specifically to the ETC version. In a previous post, I delved into this interesting quote I found:
A war on the scale of 2 years is a war of economics.
A war on the scale of 20 years is a war of technology.
A war on the scale of 200 years is a war of ideology.
Check out that post for some more explanation and thoughts on this.
Turns out, the first time I ruminated on the quote, was for this ETC Summit talk. These time scales maybe make sense for the physical world, but when it comes the digital memetic wars between internet communities, maybe we have to compress these time scales:
A digital war on the scale of 2 months is war of economics.
A digital war on the scale of 2 years is a war of technology.
A digital war on the scale of 2 decades is a war of ideology.
After all, there’s a common joke in the crypto space that 1 blockchain year is like 10 normal years. 😁
So what does this have to do with Ethereum Classic? Well, we can see the “war” between Ethereum and Ethereum Classic as an ideological dispute. Without casting any personal judgement on the matter here, but if the Ethereum Classic folks believe their chain is the morally superior one, they cannot depend on that alone to grant them victory in the chain war.
ETC is clearly currently losing the war. And its because the short-game was won through economics. The Ethereum Foundation chose to back the DAOfork chain and had the funding and resources (and trademarks) to promote it and win that battle.
Now we’re well into Stage 2; this digital war has been going on for nearly 4 years now. The Ethereum Classic community should be focused all its energy on the technology. And Ethereum is currently kicking ETC’s butt on this front. The tooling is far superior, the protocol upgrades are more regular, and the roadmap is more clearly defined. Recently, the Ethereum Classic community has been getting better — caught up on opcodes with the Atlantis hardfork, better Metamask integration, etc. But most of this has just been playing catchup to Ethereum.
If the Ethereum Classic community wants to try to make a comeback in the mid-game, they need to actually innovate. Ethereum is charging ahead with Proof of Stake and sharding and so much more. In the talk I provide a potential proposal, for what in my opinion is a much more sane and reasonable approach to achieve PoS/sharding than Ethereum is taking. But ETC doesn’t have to have the same goals at Ethereum, but they need to have some technological goals!
Disclaimer: I’m not an Ethereum Classic insider by any means. I even forewarned as much in the title of the talk — A Peripheral Observer and Fan’s View of Ethereum Classic. Yet for some reason, I often find myself known as the “Ethereum Classic guy” in the Ethereum circles. Idk, I like to wear an Ethereum Classic shirt occasionally.